Lock v. British Gas

The Advocate General has delivered his opinion in Case C-539/12, Lock v. British Gas.

The case is about the level of pay in respect of annual leave required under Article 7 of the Working Time Directive and, in particular, commission payments. When he took annual leave, Mr Lock received commission based on past sales he had made; but he was not paid any sum for commission he would have earned if he were not on annual leave. Rejecting the argument of British Gas that it was sufficient that he received pay for commission during annual leave, AG Bot said that commission was part of Mr Lock’s normal remuneration and which was linked with tasks he was required to perform. If he were not paid it in respect of his period of annual leave, there was a risk of deterring him from taking annual leave. Accordingly the Directive required that he was paid it in respect of the period of annual leave and not only during annual leave. If the Court of Justice follows the AG’s Opinion, the case will potentially benefit the many thousands of workers who are paid wholly or in part by commission.

Michael Ford QC and Simon Cheetham, instructed by Shantha David of UNISON, represented Mr Lock.

The AG's Opinion is available on the Court of Justice's website. CLICK HERE

Thursday, December 05, 2013
Metropolitan Police race discrimination case begins
Old Square team win case regarding classification under MHPS type procedures
Lu v. Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust
Otis Ferry criticised by a judge for his joint attack on two hunt monitors
Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority v First-Tier Tribunal (Social Entitlement Chamber)
  News Archive »
Michelle Fynes v. St George's Hospital NHS Trust
Lu v. Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust
The Queen on the Application of UNISON v. The Lord Chancellor and The Equality and Human Rights Commission (Intervener)
Deborah Harrod & others v. Chief Constable of West Midlands Police and others
Chhabra v West London Mental Health NHS Trust
  Cases Archive »
Melanie Tether examines the TUPE Regulations
Costs Budgeting: Recent Developments
How not to run a professional disciplinary case
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - An Overview of the Key Provisions & ET Fees
Strike Out (3) - Mark Whitcombe examines the employment tribunal's approach to striking out
  Articles Archive »